Where it stands
How F05B compares with every other domain
Every domain with thirty or more decided applications, from the lowest allowance rate to the highest; the dashed line is F05B. Switch the measure.
In plain words
In F05B, 69% of applications were allowed within three years of the first office action, against 72% for the USPTO. An allowance took 1.4 rejections on average, against 1.6 for the USPTO. The first action takes 21.4 months on average.
Where it stands
Every domain with thirty or more decided applications, from the lowest allowance rate to the highest; the dashed line is F05B. Switch the measure.
Timeline
Allowed in green, abandoned in red, pending in grey. The figures above and every chart that can be recomputed by filing year follow the span you pick; the rest are marked all years.
Ask the record
Grant rate from the first action
The gold line is this record and the blue line is the USPTO. The marker is the three-year grant rate.
Outcome simulator
A model of this record’s own transitions: each examiner action, the response to it, and what came next. Thin data borrows from the USPTO.
Prosecution paths
Every application’s sequence of examiner actions, from the first action to the outcome. Hover a band for the count.
Compared with the office
The same figures for this record and for the whole office.
Allowance over time
Share allowed (gold) and abandoned (red) by month since filing, with pending cases counted only while they are pending.
Rejection fingerprint
Share of office actions raising each ground; blue is the USPTO.
After a response
How often each ground is gone from the next action once it has been answered.
What works
Allowance rate among decided cases where each move was used at least once, against the USPTO.
Interviews
Allowance with and without an examiner interview, and how often interviews happen.
Odds by round
After the first, second and later rejections.
Response clock
How long the office takes to act once a response is in.
Quarter-end timing
Allowances by week of the USPTO fiscal quarter. An even spread would put 15% in the last two weeks.
Cited art
From the rejections in the most recently decided applications.
Trend
Is it getting easier or harder? Gold is this record, blue is the USPTO.
Appeals
Appeals filed, briefs, examiner’s answers, and how the Board decided.
Inventors
Named inventors by the number of applications in F05B.
Places
Cities by the number of applications with an inventor there.
The record in depth
Filed and granted
Filed by the year of filing, granted by the year the patent issued; the best year for grants was 2013 with 4.
Where it is examined
How many applications each tech center and art unit took, and how they fared there against what the unit usually allows.
Bars show the share of decided applications allowed in each; the white mark is what that unit allows across every applicant.
Who appears here
Applications across, allowance rate up; larger bubbles took longer. Click a bubble to open it.
Inventors
Named inventors by the number of these applications they are on.
The cost of this record
What prosecution takes after filing, priced two ways. The same examiner can cost twice what another costs.
| Actions | Months | At firm rates | With Patly | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| This record | 2.4 | 27 | $7,836 | $1,834 |
Averages over 420 decided applications, granted and abandoned alike. Firm rates are assumptions: $2,800 per response, $600 per interview, $7,500 per appeal. The Patly column swaps in its published $299 per office action response and keeps everything else the same. USPTO fees for RCEs are counted in both. Drafting and filing are not included.
Indicative portfolio value
Each asset of this domain priced on its own from its field, its age and what its prosecution shows, then added up. A package this size would trade below the sum.
An indicative range read from the record, not an appraisal. The claims are not read, and evidence of use, family members abroad, licenses and maintenance fees are not in the record: each can move a real price more than everything shown here. The starting range is an assumption for a routine granted US patent in a brokered sale; a buyer whose product the claims block can pay several times more.
Explore the record
Hover any mark for the case behind it, click to open it, and download any view as an image or a table.
Every application
Filed across, months to the decision up; green allowed, red abandoned, blue pending; larger dots drew more rejections. Drag across the years to zoom, click a dot to open the case.
The draw
Sized by applications, colored by allowance rate. A red tile is a hard unit; click one to see its examiners.
Decision calendar
Ten years of allowances, abandonments and first actions. Switch the measure to see each.
Rejections over time
The share of examined applications that drew each ground, by filing year. Click a ground to hide or show it.
Prosecution, case by case
Each row is one application from filing to its end: rejections, responses, interviews, RCEs and the outcome. Hover a mark for the date; click a row to open the case.
Examiners
| Examiner | Cases in F05B | Overall allowance rate | Difficulty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Christopher M Verdier | 2 | 74% | Typical for peers |
| Jesse M Prager | 2 | 66% | Harder than peers |
| Brian O Peters | 2 | 78% | Typical for peers |
| Joseph Ortega | 2 | 78% | Typical for peers |
| Joshua R Beebe | 1 | 71% | Typical for peers |
| Viet P Nguyen | 1 | 70% | Harder than peers |
| Sean Jerrard Younger | 1 | 57% | Harder than peers |
| Brian P Wolcott | 1 | 79% | Typical for peers |
| Moshe K Wilensky | 1 | 77% | Typical for peers |
| Matthew J Smith | 1 | 60% | Harder than peers |
| Flemming Saether | 1 | 67% | Typical for peers |
| Vishal I Patel | 1 | 82% | Easier than peers |
| Javaid H Nasri | 1 | 87% | Typical for peers |
| Tinh Dang | 1 | 89% | Typical for peers |
| Frank D Lopez | 1 | 68% | Harder than peers |
| Christopher Ryan Legendre | 1 | 77% | Typical for peers |
| Dang D Le | 1 | 81% | Typical for peers |
| Jessica L Laux | 1 | 59% | Harder than peers |
| Igor Kershteyn | 1 | 93% | Easier than peers |
| Wesley G Harris | 1 | 75% | Typical for peers |
| Colby M Hansen | 1 | 86% | Typical for peers |
| Mark C Hageman | 1 | 78% | Typical for peers |
| Benjamin F Fiorello | 1 | 78% | Easier than peers |
| Jason Gregory Davis | 1 | 76% | Typical for peers |
| Michael C Zarroli | 1 | 77% | Easier than peers |